Blue Jays Recall Davis Schneider to Start at Second Base Against Athletics
When the Toronto Blue Jays called up Davis Schneider from Triple-A Buffalo on a quiet Sunday in late April 2025, few fans expected it to be the turning point in his season. But there he was — starting at second base, batting seventh, and stepping into the batter’s box against the Oakland Athletics — replacing the injured Daulton Varsho, who’d been sidelined with a hamstring strain since March 24. It wasn’t just a roster move. It was a second chance. And for a player who’s been both beloved and baffling in equal measure, that meant everything.
A Story of Resilience in a Franchise Built on Development
Schneider, 26, didn’t come up through the usual pipeline. Drafted in the 28th round out of high school in 2017, he was the kind of pick teams hope pays off — not because he was a superstar prospect, but because he worked relentlessly. He began with the Vancouver Canadians, then moved to the New Hampshire Fisher Cats, where he hit .283 with 17 extra-base hits and 10 steals in 46 games. By the time he reached Triple-A Buffalo in September 2024, he was a different player: 21 homers, 64 RBIs, a .969 OPS. July alone? .348 average, 1.265 OPS. That’s not just promising — that’s franchise-caliber potential.The Rollercoaster of 2024 and Early 2025
His 2024 season started with promise. Through April and May, Schneider carried an .824 OPS — the power bat the Blue Jays needed in the middle of the order. Then, something broke. His swing got tangled. His timing vanished. By August, he was hitting .159 with a .499 OPS. Fans grew quiet. Analysts questioned his role. Yet, the organization never gave up on him. Coaches praised his work ethic. Teammates called him “beloved.” Even when he was benched, he stayed in the cage after games, grinding through drills, watching film, adjusting. He didn’t sulk. He didn’t complain. He just kept showing up. Spring training in 2025 was his redemption arc. He hit .345 with a 1.155 OPS in 16 games — two homers, nine walks, just 11 strikeouts. Sportsnet’s Arden Zwelling confirmed he’d made the Opening Day roster. But the moment he stepped back into regular play, the old struggles returned. In his first 10 games of 2025, he went 1-for-15. The Blue Jays, desperate for left-handed power, gave late-inning opportunities to others. Schneider was optioned to Buffalo on September 23, 2025 — a move that felt like the end of the road.Why This Recall Matters
This isn’t just about filling a spot. Varsho’s injury created a void in center field, but the Blue Jays didn’t call up a center fielder. They called up Schneider — a utility infielder — to play second base. Why? Because they believe in his bat. They believe in his ability to adjust. And they believe that, despite the numbers, he’s still one of their best development stories. Schneider’s story isn’t unique in baseball — many players hit walls. But what sets him apart is the emotional connection he’s built. His City Connect jersey sold out within hours of its release in 2024. Kids in the stands wear his number. The clubhouse sees him as a quiet leader. When he was optioned, teammates texted him: “We’re still rooting for you.” That kind of respect doesn’t come from stats. It comes from character.What’s Next?
The next 10 days will tell the real story. Can Schneider rediscover his July 2024 swing? Can he handle the pressure of starting every day? The Blue Jays aren’t just testing his bat — they’re testing their own philosophy. They’ve built a reputation on developing overlooked players. Schneider is the living proof of that. If he succeeds, it reinforces their model. If he fails, it’s still not a failure — it’s a lesson. For now, he’s back. Batting seventh. Playing second. Eyes on the ball. No grand speeches. No fanfare. Just a guy who’s been through the fire and is willing to walk back in.
Background: The Making of a 28th-Round Gem
Schneider’s journey began in a small town in Pennsylvania, where he played shortstop on a team that barely had enough uniforms. The Blue Jays took him in the 28th round — 847th overall — because they saw something others didn’t: a hitter with natural bat speed and an unshakable work ethic. He never had the tools to be a top prospect. But he had something better — discipline. He didn’t rely on athleticism. He relied on preparation. His Triple-A stats in 2024 weren’t flukes. They were the result of hundreds of hours in the cage, working with hitting coach Tom Goodwin to simplify his swing. He cut out the extra movement. He stopped trying to hit home runs. He started hitting line drives. And for a month, it worked. The question now is whether he can do it again — under the spotlight, with a team watching.What This Means for the Blue Jays’ Future
The Blue Jays have a crowded infield. Bo Bichette, Alejandro Kirk, and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. dominate headlines. But depth matters. If Schneider can stabilize second base while Varsho recovers — and if he can hit lefties even at a .250 clip — he becomes an invaluable piece. More than that: he becomes a symbol. In a league where young players are often discarded after a slump, Schneider’s return signals that Toronto still values resilience over raw stats.Frequently Asked Questions
Why did the Blue Jays pick Schneider over other prospects?
Despite his low 2025 average, Schneider’s Triple-A performance (.969 OPS, 21 HRs) and spring training numbers (1.155 OPS) showed he still has elite power potential. More importantly, the organization values his clubhouse presence and consistency in pressure situations — traits that scouts can’t quantify but managers rely on. He’s also a left-handed bat, which is scarce in Toronto’s current lineup.
How does Schneider’s 2024 collapse compare to other Blue Jays players?
Schneider’s second-half drop (.824 to .499 OPS) was steeper than most, but not unprecedented. In 2022, Lourdes Gurriel Jr. hit .278 in April-May but fell to .218 by August. What makes Schneider’s case different is his continued trust from management — a sign the team believes his struggles were mechanical, not mental. His work ethic and minor-league success suggest he’s more likely to rebound than a player with inconsistent fundamentals.
What’s Schneider’s role if Varsho returns?
If Varsho returns healthy, Schneider will likely shift to a bench role, primarily facing left-handed pitchers. He’s hit .281 with a .903 OPS against lefties in his career, compared to .182/.571 against righties. He could also spell Bo Bichette at second base or fill in at shortstop if needed — making him a valuable utility piece even without a starting job.
Is Schneider’s 2025 performance a sign he’s not MLB-ready?
Not necessarily. His .067 average in 10 games is a small sample size — equivalent to just 15 at-bats. Many MLB hitters go through 1-for-20 slumps early in the season. What’s telling is that his walk rate (9 walks in 10 games) remained high, suggesting he’s still seeing pitches well. His real issue is contact quality, not plate discipline. With adjustments, he’s far from washed up.
How does Schneider’s story reflect the Blue Jays’ organizational philosophy?
Toronto has built a reputation for developing overlooked talent — think of Alejandro Kirk or Jordan Groshans. Schneider fits that mold: a late-round pick who didn’t have elite tools but maximized his potential through discipline. His recall signals that the Blue Jays prioritize long-term growth over short-term results, a philosophy that’s helped them become consistent contenders despite not always signing big-name free agents.
What’s the timeline for his next opportunity to prove himself?
Schneider will get at least 5-7 starts over the next 10 days while Varsho recovers. If he gets a hit in his first 10 at-bats of this stretch — say, a double or a home run — he’ll likely stay in the lineup. The team has no immediate plans to send him back down, and with the schedule softening after the Athletics series, he’ll have time to rebuild confidence. His next real test comes against the Yankees on May 5, when he’ll face Gerrit Cole — a matchup that could define his season.
John Smith
I'm a real estate enthusiast with a passion for finding the perfect property. I have been investing in real estate for years and I am always looking for new opportunities. I'm always eager to learn more about the industry and to help others find their perfect home.